Free shipping on all orders over $100
Sensible Bakery

Gluten-free. Vegan. Made for everyone.

Baking thoughtfully in Long Island City since 1992, without compromising on flavor.

Featured at

Butterfield MarketMacy’sNBCDeborah MillerFrench Market PlaceThe August Tree

What we bake

Cakes
Cookies
Muffins
Loaves
Pies
Bars & Brownies

Need it today?

Order by noon for same-day pickup in Long Island City, or delivery across NYC. Last-minute cakes are kind of our thing.

Free pickup, LIC

Usually ready in a few hours. Order by noon and it is same day.

NYC delivery

Our own route across the city, same day on cakes.

Nationwide shipping

Cookies travel anywhere. Baked to order, so they arrive fresh.

Most ordered

what people come back for

Est. 1992 · Long Island City

Thirty-four years of doing it the hard way.

Sensible Bakery has called New York City home since 1992. We use only the freshest, most wholesome organic ingredients in our vegan and gluten-free baked goods — keeping health and allergens in mind.

Allergens

People’s lives are at stake, so we eliminate cross-contamination with strict allergen protocols.

Clean ingredients

Fresh, organic, sustainably sourced. No chemicals, no preservatives, no assembly lines.

10% donated

To local organizations feeding the hungry and the homeless, and to environmental restoration.

Our story

In their words

★★★★★

“I cannot have gluten and dairy, so a lot of the time I miss out on desserts. But this place is like no other. Many of these places cater only to either gluten-free or vegan, but this place does both.”

Moto P.

★★★★★

“Cakes to cookies to brownies and more — and they don’t even taste vegan and gluten-free. The prices are great, and I would definitely come here again.”

Verified buyer

Wholesale

Stock Sensible Bakery in your shop or cafe. Trade pricing, standing orders, our own delivery route.

Get started
Sensible Bakery
Meet the Baker
Social
Legal

© 2026 Sensible Bakery