Sensible Bakery

Coconut Custard Pie

Slow baked custard under toasted coconut.

Best within 3 days.
$35.99
  • Vegan
  • Gluten-Free
  • Fiber

Simple ingredients.

Organic desulfurized coconut, organic coconut cream, organic tofu, organic cane sugar, cornstarch¹, vanilla extract, sea salt. Crust: Certified gluten-free rice flour¹, certified gluten-free tapioca flour¹, certified gluten-free organic oat flour¹, certified gluten-free potato starch¹, organic cane sugar, expelled pressed organic vegan butter [coconut, sustainable ethical palm fruit, hi-oleic sunflower, flaxseed, organic natural flavor, tocopherols, organic annatto extract], organic xanthan gum, sea salt. Allergen: Contains soy. ¹ = Certified gluten-free


Size: Large (10 inch)

1

Local roots, less waste

We source locally, which supports our community, cuts carbon emissions, and backs growers who care for their soil. Everything ships in repurposed, food-safe boxes.

Get it your way

Free pickup in LIC. Local delivery across NYC, and nationwide shipping.

Made by humans

Mass-produced food is built to cut costs. Ours isn’t. Sensible products are baked in our Long Island City kitchen, with love by humans, for humans.

More treats you’ll love

© 2026 Sensible Bakery