Custom Cake
Tell us what you're picturing.
Best within 3 days.
$135.00
Size: 6"
Sponge: Vanilla
Frosting: Vanilla
Anything else we should know?
1
Local roots, less waste
We source locally, which supports our community, cuts carbon emissions, and backs growers who care for their soil. Everything ships in repurposed, food-safe boxes.
Pickup or local delivery
Too delicate to ship. Free pickup in Long Island City, or our own delivery route across NYC.
Made by humans
Mass-produced food is built to cut costs. Ours isn’t. Sensible products are baked in our Long Island City kitchen, with love by humans, for humans.
More treats you’ll love
Sensible Bakery
© 2026 Sensible Bakery